Skip to content


Things IDEA Could Learn From NetBeans

After using NetBeans 5.5 for a few days now, I’ve found a few really neat features I really wish I had in IntelliJ IDEA:

  • Code generation – The ability to generate “Entity Classes from Database” and “JSF Pages from Entity Classes” (a la Ruby on Rails scaffold generator) is a good way to jump start development.
  • Built in HTTP monitor – I know there’s a plugin (maybe several), but it really should be integrated.
  • Having a seperate classpath for test cases – This is the one thing that has always driven me nuts about IntelliJ.
  • Collapse regular block comments – This seems so natural, I’ve never understood why Idea didn’t do this
  • It’s open source – Is this really a feature? I like not feeling guilty when I write code…
  • C/C++ pack – I haven’t tried it out, but the thought of finally having basic refactoring support for C/C++ is really appealing.

All that said, I’m not sure if I can stay away from IDEA for too long, it still has features unlike any other IDE, e.g. recognition for camel hump words and hyperlinking from any file type (XML -> Java), and advanced refactoring support just for starters. Despite the significant speed improvement with NB5.5, IDEA is still faster (though it’s becoming bloated).

Posted in Java.


2 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Adrian Milliner says

    I’m hopping between Idea (6 beta), NB (55beta2) and Eclipse (3.2), 30%/40%/30%

    Only using Eclipse because my team’s tools are Eclipse-based.

    I prefer NB, but for serious coding fluidity, Idea still has the edge.

    Given the pace of change with NB, I see Idea dropping out… especially when Jackpot matures.

  2. jtanium says

    Yikes! I wasn’t expecting to get any comments…

    Thanks for mentioning Jackpot, I hadn’t heard about it. Jackpot seems seems to do a lot of what IDEA’s ‘Static Code Analysis’ does, which will be handy.

    This is the first time I haven’t jumped right into using the EAP IDEA, I just didn’t see any features I really care about, and feel IDEA is already too slow.



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.